The O'Dell Case

Patricia and Ray O'Dell's four home schooled children, Elizabeth (8), Angela (11), Samantha (14) and Andrew (15), are still being held hostage by Vermont Social Rehabilitative Services (SRS) on the bogus charge of 'educational neglect'.  These children continue to be subjected to forced separation from their parents, forced public schooling, forced immunizations, verbal and physical abuse in the foster homes (I have photos to prove it), and a multitude of other violations of their civil, constitutional and God-given rights as American citizens.

Before SRS intervention, and after their Fair Haven home burned to the ground three days after Christmas in December 2000, this family lived quite comfortably on their own in hotels (with room service, cable TV, shower and toilet facilities, continental breakfast, etc.), with family members or camping in the lush green forests of Vermont during the warmer months.  During this time, the family worked to prepare their new home on Hunter Brook Road in South Newfane, Vermont, where they had purchased, outright, a one acre lot and a used mobile home which they planned to install.  Local officials, with the blessings of the SRS and Vermont Department of Education, harassed the O'Dell family continuously to the point of driving them off their own property and out of state.

The O'Dell children were seized by SRS, with the brute force of the state police, on Friday, September 13, 2002, at the home of Patricia O'Dell's ill mother.  Since the seizure, the children have been forced to live apart from their parents, family members and friends and have been denied the affections and support of these same people.  During supervised visits (which only take place once or twice a week at the whim of the social worker, Athena Bolger), the O'Dell's are not allowed to cry, hug each other, comfort each other or share information.  This family is taunted, scolded, provoked and belittled by whomever is assigned to sit in the room at the time of these visits, making it a very stressful experience for both parents and children.

The children were denied any contact with their parents on their mother's birthday in September, and on Thanksgiving day.  As it stands now, SRS is planning to deny these children any contact with their parents on Christmas day as well.  Patricia and Ray O'Dell are loving parents to their children; I can attest to that.  They have struggled for years to make a better life for themselves and to not become a burden on the taxpayers by accepting welfare programs.  They live on very little income but they own their S. Newfane property outright.  They chose to home school their children because the public schools failed to give their children an education and actually held them back (there is documentation to prove this) in their learning.

The O'Dells are being treated unfairly and unjustly.  The state of Vermont has simply confiscated their children because the O'Dells chose to home school them.  Their choice to home school meant the local school lost thousands of dollars in funding and the school was not happy about that.  It was the decision of the Fair Haven Elementary principal, Gloria Moulton, to 'go after' the O'Dell family two months after their home burned and to make their life a living hell.  Ms. Moulton's decision (and many threats) worked its way through the channels of the DOE's bureaucratic behemoth via Natalie Casco (Home Study Consultant) where it was decided the O'Dell family would be denied their constitutional right to home school.  Once Casco labeled the case 'educational neglect' (a term which she herself could not define on Ruth Dwyer's Hard Look broadcast on ABC 22 TV news on Thursday, November 14, 2002) the case was then handed over to SRS.

Patricia and Ray had a hearing scheduled for Thursday, December 5, 2002, to determine whether their children would be returned to them.  Because of the incompetence of the public defender assigned to the case, a continuance was issued and the hearing postponed.  The children are devastated because they thought they were coming home.  Senator Mark Shepard (R) of Bennington has been lending a hand and moral support to the O'Dells but the game playing by Athena Bolger and other SRS members continues.

For more information on how you may help this family, please contact Cindy Wade, a friend of the family and author of this piece.

December 2002